THE LAST DITCH An Englishman returned after twenty years abroad blogs about liberty in Britain
The first of many eBay listings?
An afternoon walk in Shanghai

Does The Guardian know the truth?

Charlotte Raven: Should I take my own life? | Society | The Guardian.

The linked article in The Guardian is a very sad piece. The author has Huntington's, an incurable degenerative disease perhaps best know for afflicting the character Dr Remy "Thirteen" Hadley in the wonderful American TV drama "House". The symptoms might, as she writes, have been devised by an evil genius in a comic strip:

What could be more testing than an illness that impairs quickly but takes decades to kill – or more cruel than one that robs you of your ability to communicate while leaving your capacity to understand intact?
She speculates as to how things might go wrong for her and her family as the disease takes its terrible course and discusses, very rationally, the pros and cons of suicide. My religious readers may be shocked by her reasoning. I confess that am not.

The Left in Britain are very big on the right to die. On occasion, they have even floated the idea of a duty to die. So it's not surprising to find a piece like this in their house journal. I was startled however by two bullet points that could surely never appear in that statist rag in any other context;
  • Without autonomy and the capacity for self-­determination, life is meaningless. Merely ­existing isn't enough.
  • Dependency is degrading.

I could not agree more. However, if The Guardian truly agreed, how different would its editorial policy have to be? 


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Brian, follower of Deornoth

An acquaintance of mine is suffering from this dreadful condition, but I don't see why he should be under any duty to die. He's a pretty good bridge player; rather better than I am, and I'll hold his cards any time he likes. Not just to do him a favour, although I'd be happy to do that, but because I'd learn a lot from him.

The comments to this entry are closed.